3835 Views
137 Downloads |
Assessing the impact of labour market spendings on unemployment dynamics across demographics in OECD countries
Osama Shaikh*
Article | Year: 2025 | Pages: 527 - 562 | Volume: 49 | Issue: 4 Received: April 19, 2025 | Accepted: November 7, 2025 | Published online: December 2, 2025
|
FULL ARTICLE
FIGURES & DATA
REFERENCES
CROSSMARK POLICY
METRICS
LICENCING
PDF
|
Variable
|
Type
|
Description
|
Combined unit
of measure
|
|
YUNP
|
Dependent
|
Youth unemployment
rate
|
% of youth labour
force, aged 15-24
|
|
AUNP
|
Adult unemployment
rate
|
% of adult labour
force, aged 25+
|
|
UNP
|
Total unemployment
rate
|
% of total labour
force, aged 15+
|
|
APWEMI
|
Independent
|
Public expenditure
on active labour market policies without employment incentives
|
% of GDP
|
|
LNITI
|
Institutional
training investments (logged)
|
National currency
in millions
|
|
LNTRI
|
Public training
expenditure (logged)
|
|
LNMIB
|
Minimum income
benefits (logged)
|
National currency
|
|
LNAAW
|
Average annual
wages (logged)
|
USD, PPP-adjusted,
constant 2023 prices
|
|
LNLFPR
|
Labor force participation
rate (logged)
|
Number of economically
active persons
|
Source: OECD, 2024.
|
Variable
|
CD statistic
|
CDw statistic
|
CDw+ statistic
|
CD* statistic
|
|
YUNP
|
37.10*
|
-0.98
|
1,085.50*
|
-0.87
|
|
AUNP
|
31.91*
|
-0.96
|
1,043.22*
|
3.27*
|
|
UNP
|
35.13*
|
1.48
|
1,060.59*
|
3.30*
|
|
APWEMI
|
8.53*
|
-1.24
|
957.69*
|
2.48*
|
|
LNMIB
|
43.26*
|
-0.50
|
1,745.27*
|
-1.40
|
|
LNITI
|
0.62
|
-2.11*
|
812.28*
|
-0.78
|
|
LNTRI
|
2.17**
|
1.80***
|
812.12*
|
0.82
|
|
LNAAW
|
58.41*
|
-1.32
|
1,895.72*
|
-0.96
|
|
LNLFPR
|
52.94*
|
-1.90*
|
2,134.33*
|
-1.00
|
Note: *, **, and ***, represents significance at 1%, 5%, and at 10%, respectively.
|
Variables
|
Trend
|
CIPS I(0)
|
CIPS I(1)
|
|
YUNP
|
Yes
|
-1.85
|
-3.21*
|
|
AUNP
|
No
|
-2.01
|
-2.74*
|
|
UNP
|
-2.06
|
-2.65*
|
|
APWEMI
|
-2.02
|
-3.69*
|
|
LNMIB
|
-1.23
|
-3.91*
|
|
LNITI
|
-1.47
|
-3.45*
|
|
LNTRI
|
-1.67
|
-3.69*
|
|
LNAAW
|
-1.89
|
-3.45*
|
|
LNLFPR
|
-1.46
|
-3.47*
|
Note: *, **, and ***, represents significance at 1%, 5%, and at 10%, respectively.
|
Variable
|
t-statistic
|
E1
|
E2
|
E3
|
E4
|
E5
|
|
YUNP
|
Δ
|
10.84*
|
8.87*
|
11.96*
|
16.53*
|
14.59*
|
|
Δadj
|
12.20*
|
9.98*
|
13.46*
|
18.60*
|
16.42*
|
|
AUNP
|
Δ
|
9.93*
|
7.53*
|
10.92*
|
12.59*
|
13.19*
|
|
Δadj
|
11.17*
|
8.48*
|
12.29*
|
14.17*
|
14.85*
|
|
UNP
|
Δ
|
11.32*
|
9.38*
|
12.84*
|
16.13*
|
15.28*
|
|
Δadj
|
12.74*
|
10.56*
|
14.45*
|
18.16*
|
17.19*
|
Note: *, **, and ***, represents significance at 1%, 5%, and at 10%, respectively.
|
Variable
|
t-statistic
|
E1
|
E2
|
E3
|
E4
|
E5
|
|
YUNP
|
Gt
|
-2.08*
|
-1.93*
|
-1.91*
|
-2.56*
|
-2.72*
|
|
Ga
|
-5.00
|
-4.82
|
-5.11
|
-4.51
|
-4.60
|
|
Pt
|
-11.33*
|
-14.26*
|
-14.00*
|
-14.20*
|
-17.00*
|
|
Pa
|
-4.20*
|
-4.95*
|
-5.03*
|
-3.99*
|
-5.38*
|
|
AUNP
|
Gt
|
-1.87*
|
-1.89*
|
-1.91*
|
-2.35*
|
-2.52*
|
|
Ga
|
-4.96
|
-4.58
|
-5.00
|
-5.00
|
-4.59
|
|
Pt
|
-10.32*
|
-13.52*
|
-13.80*
|
-12.71*
|
-13.65*
|
|
Pa
|
-4.06*
|
-4.95*
|
-5.16*
|
-3.92*
|
-4.52*
|
|
UNP
|
Gt
|
-2.13*
|
-1.99*
|
-1.98*
|
-2.62*
|
-2.78*
|
|
Ga
|
-5.13
|
-4.81
|
-5.17
|
-4.70
|
-4.75
|
|
Pt
|
-11.57*
|
-14.73*
|
-14.56*
|
-14.63*
|
-17.63*
|
|
Pa
|
-4.31*
|
-5.10*
|
-5.18*
|
-4.20*
|
-5.65*
|
Note: *, **, and ***, represents significance at 1%, 5%, and at 10%, respectively.
|
Eq. No.
|
Dependent variable
|
Independent
variable
|
CCEMG
|
MG
|
FMOLS
|
|
E1
|
YUNP
|
APWEMI
|
117.38
|
18.81***
|
9.64*
|
|
LNITI
|
-26.17**
|
-1.20
|
-0.37*
|
|
E2
|
APWEMI
|
18.69
|
29.97***
|
8.98*
|
|
LNTRI
|
-2.17
|
-1.95
|
-0.08*
|
|
E3
|
APWEMI
|
12.15**
|
12.90*
|
6.18*
|
|
LNMIB
|
1.45
|
0.70
|
1.19*
|
|
E4
|
APWEMI
|
74.34***
|
14.37*
|
1.28*
|
|
LNAAW
|
2.54
|
2.35
|
1.51*
|
|
E5
|
APWEMI
|
4.47
|
7.80**
|
3.27*
|
|
LNLFPR
|
24.53***
|
16.83*
|
1.85*
|
|
E6
|
AUNP
|
APWEMI
|
7.79***
|
6.93**
|
5.13*
|
|
LNITI
|
-0.93
|
-0.21
|
-0.19*
|
|
E7
|
APWEMI
|
6.37
|
8.26
|
4.81*
|
|
LNTRI
|
-0.85
|
-0.18
|
-0.06*
|
|
E8
|
APWEMI
|
5.16**
|
6.16*
|
2.09*
|
|
LNMIB
|
1.00***
|
0.54
|
0.44*
|
|
E9
|
APWEMI
|
1.04
|
2.13
|
0.41*
|
|
LNAAW
|
8.24**
|
2.72**
|
0.55*
|
|
E10
|
APWEMI
|
0.19
|
1.72
|
1.18*
|
|
LNLFPR
|
14.91**
|
8.24*
|
0.63*
|
|
E11
|
UNP
|
APWEMI
|
9.39***
|
12.76**
|
6.37*
|
|
LNITI
|
-1.14
|
-0.83
|
-0.32*
|
|
E12
|
APWEMI
|
2.04
|
11.08**
|
5.68*
|
|
LNTRI
|
-9.66***
|
-0.54
|
-0.08*
|
|
E13
|
APWEMI
|
6.16**
|
7.17*
|
2.61*
|
|
LNMIB
|
1.43**
|
0.55*
|
0.51*
|
|
E14
|
APWEMI
|
1.37
|
6.19**
|
0.58*
|
|
LNAAW
|
9.31**
|
2.24
|
0.66*
|
|
E15
|
APWEMI
|
2.01
|
2.11
|
1.45*
|
|
LNLFPR
|
16.46**
|
9.38*
|
0.75*
|
Note: *, **, and ***, represents significance at 1%, 5%, and at 10%, respectively.
|
Eq. no.
|
Dependent variable
|
Independent variable
|
Pre-crisis
|
Post-crisis
|
Pre-pandemic
|
Post-covid
|
|
E1
|
YUNP
|
APWEMI
|
-0.38
|
14.13*
|
15.91**
|
9.25*
|
|
LNITI
|
-0.12*
|
-1.26
|
0.05
|
-1.18
|
|
E2
|
APWEMI
|
-0.16
|
14.09*
|
16.97**
|
7.77*
|
|
LNTRI
|
-0.17**
|
-1.25
|
-0.52
|
-0.24
|
|
E3
|
APWEMI
|
-1.27
|
11.40**
|
13.18**
|
5.16**
|
|
LNMIB
|
0.50
|
-0.97
|
-11.38*
|
-14.02*
|
|
E4
|
APWEMI
|
-2.81
|
12.19*
|
12.24**
|
5.33**
|
|
LNAAW
|
-32.29*
|
-31.00**
|
-33.84*
|
-56.56*
|
|
E5
|
APWEMI
|
-2.64
|
11.14**
|
14.22**
|
-0.88
|
|
LNLFPR
|
-17.79***
|
-26.78**
|
-27.47*
|
-67.11*
|
|
E6
|
AUNP
|
APWEMI
|
0.93
|
6.32*
|
7.04**
|
2.54
|
|
LNITI
|
-0.15*
|
-0.14
|
-0.12
|
-0.20
|
|
E7
|
APWEMI
|
1.05
|
6.40*
|
7.18**
|
2.52***
|
|
LNTRI
|
-0.17*
|
-0.18
|
-0.20
|
-0.17
|
|
E8
|
APWEMI
|
0.32
|
6.02*
|
5.71**
|
1.54
|
|
LNMIB
|
-0.06
|
-0.01
|
-4.62**
|
-4.86*
|
|
E9
|
APWEMI
|
-0.61
|
6.36*
|
5.22***
|
1.62
|
|
LNAAW
|
-15.53*
|
-14.49***
|
-14.36*
|
-16.66*
|
|
E10
|
APWEMI
|
-0.76
|
5.87*
|
6.11***
|
-0.68
|
|
LNLFPR
|
-11.00***
|
-12.34***
|
-10.97**
|
-23.57*
|
|
E11
|
UNP
|
APWEMI
|
2.00
|
7.13*
|
8.11**
|
3.19**
|
|
LNITI
|
-0.18*
|
-0.22
|
-0.10
|
-0.25
|
|
E12
|
APWEMI
|
2.13
|
7.19*
|
8.32**
|
2.90**
|
|
LNTRI
|
-0.20*
|
-0.25
|
-0.22
|
-0.06
|
|
E13
|
APWEMI
|
1.23
|
6.66*
|
6.64**
|
2.00
|
|
LNMIB
|
0.01
|
-0.06
|
-5.27**
|
-5.53*
|
|
E14
|
APWEMI
|
0.23
|
7.04*
|
6.09***
|
2.07
|
|
LNAAW
|
-17.30*
|
-16.12***
|
-16.45*
|
-20.11*
|
|
E15
|
APWEMI
|
0.05
|
6.50*
|
7.05**
|
-0.81
|
|
LNLFPR
|
-12.46**
|
-13.42***
|
-13.35*
|
-29.33*
|
|
Eq. no.
|
Dependent variable
|
Independent variable
|
Nordic
|
Liberal
|
Continental
|
Southern
|
Eastern
|
Other
|
|
E1
|
YUNP
|
APWEMI
|
49.48*
|
21.63**
|
135.90
|
-24.80*
|
0.20
|
68.09
|
|
LNITI
|
-21.66**
|
-1.58
|
-24.92
|
-3.46
|
-0.76
|
-6.52
|
|
E2
|
APWEMI
|
55.41*
|
16.83
|
69.87**
|
-6.27*
|
-11.97*
|
94.37
|
|
LNTRI
|
-26.42**
|
-0.95
|
-23.75
|
1.39
|
2.10*
|
-8.33
|
|
E3
|
APWEMI
|
10.38*
|
39.28**
|
7.09
|
-5.98*
|
8.25
|
-8.56*
|
|
LNMIB
|
14.01
|
6.16
|
23.20
|
-0.60
|
6.38*
|
-1.62
|
|
E4
|
APWEMI
|
10.40*
|
13.79
|
2.59
|
-9.76**
|
15.34
|
-73.79**
|
|
LNAAW
|
-2.70
|
20.24**
|
-1.56
|
8.84
|
14.63
|
-22.50*
|
|
E5
|
APWEMI
|
14.14*
|
27.97
|
4.96
|
-10.12**
|
-3.07
|
-20.82***
|
|
LNLFPR
|
62.37***
|
-54.32
|
13.02
|
-4.84
|
59.04**
|
-4.45
|
|
E6
|
AUNP
|
APWEMI
|
2.62
|
11.33**
|
0.70
|
-0.04
|
-0.13
|
-11.06
|
|
LNITI
|
-3.24*
|
-0.90
|
0.89
|
-0.10
|
-0.75***
|
-0.24
|
|
E7
|
APWEMI
|
2.16
|
10.81
|
0.32
|
-2.27*
|
-37.65***
|
37.04
|
|
LNTRI
|
-3.65**
|
-0.66
|
0.45
|
2.43
|
5.51**
|
-4.27
|
|
E8
|
APWEMI
|
-5.60
|
6.59*
|
1.57
|
0.61
|
5.45
|
-2.06*
|
|
LNMIB
|
37.54**
|
-1.86
|
4.00
|
-1.13*
|
2.12**
|
-0.70
|
|
E9
|
APWEMI
|
1.59
|
1.52
|
-2.63
|
0.40
|
-7.66
|
-24.99***
|
|
LNAAW
|
4.17
|
10.71*
|
-32.55***
|
10.22**
|
-57.24***
|
-13.16
|
|
E10
|
APWEMI
|
1.91
|
16.59
|
1.99***
|
-1.30
|
-1.84
|
-16.74**
|
|
LNLFPR
|
16.59*
|
1.11
|
4.95
|
7.57*
|
30.37*
|
2.42
|
|
E11
|
UNP
|
APWEMI
|
4.32**
|
12.29**
|
0.66
|
0.64
|
-0.012
|
225.75
|
|
LNITI
|
-3.53**
|
-1.03
|
0.88
|
-0.75
|
-0.728***
|
-13.39**
|
|
E12
|
APWEMI
|
4.01***
|
11.58
|
0.30
|
-2.85*
|
-5.347*
|
38.86
|
|
LNTRI
|
-4.07**
|
-0.80
|
1.22
|
2.75
|
0.002
|
-5.02
|
|
E13
|
APWEMI
|
1.57
|
8.63*
|
3.51**
|
0.53
|
5.987
|
-2.74*
|
|
LNMIB
|
5.43
|
-0.58
|
3.78
|
-1.04**
|
2.597**
|
-0.78**
|
|
E14
|
APWEMI
|
2.54**
|
6.76
|
-2.84
|
-2.76
|
6.229***
|
-11.89
|
|
LNAAW
|
3.94
|
23.25*
|
-26.24**
|
8.43
|
6.559
|
-7.05
|
|
E15
|
APWEMI
|
4.16
|
15.18
|
3.13**
|
-1.94
|
-1.954
|
-18.47**
|
|
LNLFPR
|
16.09***
|
-27.85
|
2.98
|
7.58*
|
35.012*
|
-1.21
|
|
Dependent variable
|
Independent variable
|
Lag (AIC)
|
Z-bar
|
Z-bar tilde
|
Direction of causality
|
|
YUNP
|
APWEMI
|
2
|
5.50*
|
2.92*
|
YUNP ⇔ APWEMI
|
|
LNITI
|
2
|
8.07*
|
4.70*
|
YUNP ⇔ LNITI
|
|
LNTRI
|
2
|
7.03*
|
3.99*
|
YUNP ⇔ LNTRI
|
|
LNMIB
|
1
|
3.32*
|
2.06*
|
YUNP ⇔ LNMIB
|
|
LNAAW
|
2
|
5.47*
|
2.91
|
YUNP ⇔ LNAAW
|
|
LNLFPR
|
1
|
5.46*
|
3.69*
|
YUNP ⇔ LNLFPR
|
|
AUNP
|
APWEMI
|
2
|
30.02*
|
19.61*
|
AUNP ⇔ APWEMI
|
|
LNITI
|
2
|
21.38*
|
13.75*
|
AUNP ⇔ LNITI
|
|
LNTRI
|
2
|
24.15*
|
15.64*
|
AUNP ⇔ LNTRI
|
|
LNMIB
|
2
|
5.11*
|
2.68*
|
AUNP ⇔ LNMIB
|
|
LNAAW
|
2
|
11.66*
|
7.12*
|
AUNP ⇔ LNAAW
|
|
LNLFPR
|
2
|
3.97*
|
1.88*
|
AUNP ⇔ LNLFPR
|
|
UNP
|
APWEMI
|
2
|
25.50*
|
16.53*
|
UNP ⇔ APWEMI
|
|
LNITI
|
2
|
25.79*
|
16.75*
|
UNP ⇔ LNITI
|
|
LNTRI
|
2
|
25.79*
|
16.75*
|
UNP ⇔ LNTRI
|
|
LNMIB
|
2
|
4.64*
|
2.36*
|
UNP ⇔ LNMIB
|
|
LNAAW
|
2
|
10.57*
|
6.37*
|
UNP ⇔ LNAAW
|
|
LNLFPR
|
1
|
5.84*
|
3.98*
|
UNP ⇔ LNLFPR
|
|
|
December, 2025 IV/2025
|